
My friend finally got me copies of her pictures from the debate Dave did at the high school, but by the time they came the election was pretty much history so I thought I would just forget it. Kimbrey, however, is still intrigued, so I'll tell a few thing about the debate that I thought were interesting. Dave got 15 minutes at the beginning to present "his" candidate. He talked mostly about McCain's war service, in particular his POW years. One thing that brought tears to my eyes was when he mentioned someone in the senate once accused John McCain of being a carpet bagger. McCain's reply was that he came from a military family and they moved around a lot. He said he would have loved to have had the luxury of living in one place and calling it home. Then, almost as an afterthought, he said, "In fact, I believe the one place I lived the longest was Hanoi." Dave's point was that in order to effectively run the country you needed to have a deep love for the country and that he was confident that John McCain loves our country deeply. He didn't feel that Obama has that patriotic love for the US that John McCain does.
Mr. DeFrancia's main objection to John McCain seemed to be Pres. Bush. Let me pause here for a minute and just say that I think Pres. Bush has gotten a bad rap. He pretty well got crapped on his second term with 9/11 and Hurricane Katrina, to name just two biggies. I think he did the best he could under a bunch of really BAD conditions, and if I knew where to send it, I would send him a Thank You note for holding to his principles even when the populace was against him and for serving morally and with dignity. I'll bet when Obama moves into the White House there won't have just been a mass of convicts freed from prison, more Utah property tied up as protected land, and all the B's will still be on all the keyboards. ("B"arak o"B"ama, get it?)

Then they took questions. Mr. DeFrancia just kept coming back to Pres. Bush and the war and how terrible it was that we invaded another country without provocation. Dave pointed out that the war came after 9/11 AND after Saddam Hessian protected known terrorists who had killed United States citizens. Mr. DeFrancia's reply was, "It was a Republican President who put Saddam Hessian into power." So . . we shouldn't correct that? We should have just left him there? I'm not sure what Mr. D's point was, but Dave's was that we DIDN'T attack without provocation. They also brought up socialized health care. Dave countered with the fact that we have the best health care in the world here. That in places where they have socialized health care you can't get in to see a Dr. He mentioned one city in Canada (Dave served his mission in Canada) where they drew names every day to see who got to see a Dr. that day. Now, maybe I'm just stupid, but if WE can't afford our own health insurance and OUR taxes support the government, where is the government going to get the money to buy our insurance for us? If someone could answer that for me I would feel a lot better about things.

My proudest moment came when the question was asked about No Child Left Behind. I knew Dave didn't have an answer for that - I had seen his preparation paper, so when that question came up and it was his partner, David Knutson's turn to answer I was relieved. However, David K. took the mike and said, "Be brave, Dave" and handed the mike to Dave. Now, the girl standing next to Mr. D had answered that question for their side. She went on and on about bubble tests, the ACT, how testing doesn't test knowledge, blah, blah, blah, but she finally said that "No Child Left Behind was a punishment for the most important people in our lives - OUR TEACHERS!!" I was shaking in my seat as Dave took the mike, but this was his reply. He said, "I have three grandsons who we love a lot. My oldest grandson is an import (yes, he called Aiden an import) from Ohio. He just turned two years old and he can recite the whole alphabet and he can count to 15. And he has not had a school teacher in his life yet. Then he said, "I respectfully disagree with Miss S, but the most important people in your life are not your teachers, they are your parents and your family. When more parents start to take responsibility for their children's educations and stop expecting the government to do that for them, we won't have to have No Child Left Behind." I wanted to stand on my feet and cheer. But that's just not me, so I cheered and clapped from where I was sitting. He made other really good points about how teachers needed to be held to a standard just like any other person in any other occupation, that maybe testing wasn't the best way to measure a teacher, but that it is the best way we know right now.
Anyway, the outcome is different than I hoped for, but maybe Pre. Elect Obama CAN hold good on some of his promises and make things better. We can only wait and see. I'm really anticipating that middle income tax break - and having someone else pay for my health insurance. Let's see . . tax BREAK, pay more money OUT for health insurance . . . nope, doesn't add up to me, but I've never been that great at math.